ktm_525 wrote:
With the auto the collar issue is much reduced. That being said have you tried a manual version of the R? Night and day. You are on the right track since the only auto Rs to consider should be the 06&07.
Tires. Went through three sets plus a winter set in my 80ks
1) Pirelli Rosso got 16000 km's before wearing below minimum. Harsh but great handling and stick
2) Hankook V something's. less harsh but less stick, constant balance issues. Got about 30k km's before trashed.
3) Michelin Pilot Sport A/S these were pricey but the best I used. Car sold with them on.
Winters: Hankook w300 icebears. They were good and handled ok.
I was never a fan of the suspension. Too much wallow in comfort and advanced was way too harsh. Spent most of the time in sport. Upgrading the sway bars and links (ipd) helped somewhat. Hopefully you don't live in Saskatoon. My R made many trips there and it did not like the nasty pavement. Driving in town was a slalom around the worst of it.
On smooth highway the VR is a dream. Good luck and let us know how it goes.
You make valid points about the ride, but I still found it nicer than the 535 BMW Touring, and it's still much nicer than our 2000 V70R and that has new Nivo's and Koni yellows - so I am thrilled with the ride even though it's a compromise. I do have to say that after 8 hours in the 06' my butt hurt - so I think the P1 V70R has better seats. (My Peugeot kills all for ride quality on the rough stuff and seat comfort however).
Correct - I tried my buddy's 2004 V70R 6sp manual, and I was sold on the car - but my wife is the primary driver of the car, and while she can drive manual cars, she doesn't enjoy them. Knowing this - the only years to consider were 06 and 07 as I wanted the 6sp auto and all it's improvements.
Thanks for the details on the tires - my car currently has Hankook V12's which are likely done due to uneven tire wear, and they're quite noisy. Costco has Pilot Sport A/S 3's which are highly rated, but the Conti DWS's are also supposed to be very good. Was initially leaning to the Conti's - but getting Michelin's at Costco makes it very tempting.
Curious what your experiences were with the R's "side-hop" issue in the back. I've read tires and proper wheel alignment pretty much eliminate it, but curious what you found in your car? For the most part it's fine, but for the really sharp impacts it really does get unsettled and the prospect of that happening on an icy highway in winter is unsettling as the side-hop it does could very well induce a slide at speed...
Picked up the car this past Saturday - Matt and Dale picked my up from the airport and Dale graciously finished the tour of the collection after we had breakfast. Headed to get the car around 1 PM and verified the tranny was shifting much better. I wasn't sure about the WOT 1-2 and 2-3 shifts as they were pretty hard, but they were very positive with no slipping or crunching, they just felt HARD... Hard enough to chirp the tires and I don't like feeling that kind of strain in the driveline... Partial throttle shifting was beautiful (and still really fast if needed), so finished up at Bert & Jack's, grabbed lunch, and headed back home in my new R.

I was pretty gun shy at first, and traveled with the radio off listening intently to the car. It was great, so cranked the tunes and enjoyed the ride. Car was FANTASTIC on the highway and any buyers remorse I had for potentially buying a car with tranny issues subsided and it just checked all my boxes as my choice as being the right car for us. As the trip wore on I got a bit braver, and was giving it some throttle to see how it was downshifting at speed. All was fine. Happened to come across a slower car in the left lane about to pass a semi, but closing at a very slow rate which was boxing me in. Had plenty of room to pass on the right and pass the semi - but the person accelerated as I passed them as if to force me into the semi - so I punched it... HOLY CRAP! The R dropped 2 gears and left that car like it was standing still - rocketed forward and around the semi with ease... I was in LOVE... This car is HUGELY capable, and very much an "enthusiasts" family car.
OOP is tomorrow, so I find out what the car will need to pass safety... So I'll update further once I get the list of "ToDo's"...
Rabin